Boys Like Girls sorti le 22 août 2006 chez Columbia Records/Red Ink.
1. "The Great Escape" (Martin Johnson, Sam Hollander, Dave Katz) – 3:28
2. "Five Minutes to Midnight" (Johnson, Hollander, Katz) – 3:47
3. "Hero/Heroine" (Johnson) – 3:52
4. "Top of the World" (Johnson) – 3:36
5. "Thunder" (Johnson) – 3:56
6. "Me, You and My Medication" (Johnson, Bleu) – 4:28
7. "Up Against the Wall" (Johnson, Hollander, Katz) – 3:39
8. "Dance Hall Drug" (Johnson) – 3:29
9. "Learning to Fall" (Johnson, Hollander, Katz) – 3:04
10. "Heels over Head" (Johnson) – 3:08
11. "Broken Man" (Johnson) – 3:31
12. "Holiday" (Johnson) – 5:08
2 singles sont sortis à ce jour Hero/Heroine et The Great Escape